Start a project
Start a project
A sketch of a hand on a stack of tracing paper

Every mark starts in pencil

Why we draw a logo by hand before it goes near a screen, and what tracing paper still does better than any vector tool.

Identity

·

·

5 min read

5 min read
Odile Marchetti

Odile Marchetti

Identity

Odile founded Ply in 2016 and still draws every mark by hand before it goes near a screen.

Every identity we make starts the same way: a stack of tracing paper, a soft pencil and an afternoon with the phone in a drawer. It looks slow. It’s the fastest way we know to find out what a mark wants to be.

People are sometimes surprised by this. They’ve hired a studio with a website full of motion and code, and the first thing they see from us is a pile of pencil sketches held together with a bulldog clip. By the end of the project, most of them understand why.

Paper forgets nothing

On screen, every version replaces the one before it. You nudge a curve, the old curve is gone, and a week later nobody can remember what the logo looked like before the nudge. Undo only goes back so far, and nobody keeps every file.

On paper, each sheet sits on top of the last, so the rejected ideas stay visible underneath. We lay a fresh sheet over a sketch, trace only the part that works and leave the rest behind. The sheet below still shows through, faintly. By the tenth layer the mark has edited itself, and the whole history of the decision is sitting on the desk in one pile.

That pile is useful long after the drawing is finished. When a client asks why the mark leans the way it does, we can show them the sheet where it didn’t, and the sheet after that where it started to.

A pencil can’t be precise too early

Vector tools are wonderful at the end of a project and dangerous at the start. They invite you to fix things that aren’t decided yet. An hour disappears into the exact radius of a corner on a logo that might not survive the afternoon.

A pencil refuses to be precise too early. A curve drawn by hand is a decision about feeling, not about anchor points. You can’t zoom to four hundred per cent and fiddle. You have to look at the whole thing, at the size it will really be seen, and ask whether it feels right.

A curve drawn by hand is a decision about feeling, not about anchor points.

There is a practical side, too. A soft pencil on tracing paper makes a line with a little weight and wobble in it. That wobble tells us where a shape is uncertain. When we see a curve we’ve redrawn six times, we know that’s the part of the mark that needs the most thought.

A hand lettering on tracing paper with a mechanical pencil over a light box

Why tracing paper, specifically

We’ve tried most kinds of paper. Sketchbooks are lovely, but you can’t see through the pages, so every drawing starts from nothing. Layout pads are better, but the sheets are too opaque after the third layer. Tracing paper is the only thing that lets you see four or five drawings at once, stacked, each one a little clearer than the one below.

We buy it by the roll from an architects’ supplier down the road, a heavy, slightly yellow stock that takes a soft pencil without tearing. A roll lasts about two identities. It’s the cheapest thing in the studio and probably the most important.

The other tools are just as plain. A 2B pencil for drawing, a 6B for the lines we’re sure of, a putty rubber, masking tape and a desk lamp turned on its side to light the sheets from below. Nothing needs charging and nothing sends notifications.

How a drawing session goes

A first session usually lasts about three hours. We pin the client’s words on the wall: the brief, the things they told us in the first meeting, and the single sentence we agreed the identity has to say. Then we draw quickly and badly, a lot of small marks, thumbnail size, none of them precious.

After an hour we stop and spread everything out on the big table. Most of it goes in the bin. Usually three or four ideas have something in them, a gesture or a proportion or a single stroke that feels like the client. Those get a fresh sheet each, and the tracing starts.

From there it’s slow, quiet work. Trace, adjust, lay a new sheet, trace again. We talk less. The marks get bigger and simpler. When a drawing stops changing between sheets, it’s ready to go on the wall with the others.

Clients are welcome to join a session, and more of them do than you’d think. Nobody is asked to draw. They sit at the end of the table, watch the sheets pile up and say what they see. Often it’s a client who spots the idea first, pointing at a scribble in the corner of a sheet we were about to throw away. We’ve learned to keep the bin on the far side of the room.

When we finally move to the screen

By the time we open a vector file, we’re redrawing something we already believe in. The decisions about character, weight and balance have been made by hand. What’s left is craft: smoothing curves, aligning to a grid, checking the mark at sixteen pixels and at four metres.

That part of the work takes hours instead of weeks, because we’re not searching any more. We know what we’re making. If something feels wrong on screen, we print it and put tracing paper over it again. The pencil is never far away, even at the very end.

The screen does teach us one thing the pencil can’t: how the mark behaves at its smallest. A favicon is sixteen pixels square, and no hand drawing prepares you for that. So the last few sheets in every stack are drawn on graph paper, one square per pixel, to find the version of the mark that survives being tiny.

What we bring to the first meeting

We never show a client a single polished logo. We bring the stack: the sheets that led somewhere and the ones that didn’t, in the order we drew them.

It turns the conversation from “do you like it?” into “which of these feels like you?”, which is a much better question. Clients can see the thinking, point at the sheet where something started to feel right, and help us steer from there. The final mark is still ours to draw, but the choice of direction becomes something we make together.

And when the project ends, the stack goes to the client. A few of them have framed it.

A single rower on grey water, seen from above

Next note

A type family for a rowing club
A type family for a rowing club
A type family for a rowing club

Drawing letters that read from a riverbank at forty metres, and still look right stitched onto a kit bag.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.