Start a project
Start a project
A notebook with a coffee ring on a dark wooden table

The question nobody budgets for

The most useful hour in any project is the one before the brief. This is the question we ask in it.

Strategy

·

·

4 min read

4 min read
Carlota Benítez

Carlota Benítez

Strategy

Carlota leads Strategy, which mostly means asking the question nobody budgeted for and then answering it.

Briefs arrive full of answers. A new logo, a faster site, a campaign by spring. They rarely say what changed in the business to make those answers feel urgent, and that’s the part we most need to know.

A brief is a solution someone has already chosen. Sometimes it’s the right one. Often it’s the most visible one: the logo everyone can see, rather than the confusion nobody wants to name. Our first job is to find out which kind of brief we’re holding.

What would make this a waste of money?

We ask it in the first meeting, before anyone has talked about colours or competitors. It sounds blunt. It’s the kindest question we know, because it makes room for the worries people don’t put in writing: the board that won’t approve it, the sales team that won’t use it, the founder who is quietly unsure the company should be changing at all.

There is usually a pause after we ask it. Then someone answers, and it’s rarely the person who wrote the brief. It might be the operations lead, or the person who answers the phone, or the founder, who has been waiting for permission to say the thing out loud.

The answers decide the work, and they’re almost never what the brief says.

We write down every answer, word for word, on a large sheet of paper on the wall. By the end of the hour, that sheet is more useful than the brief. It tells us what success would actually look like, and what failure would feel like to each person in the room.

A quiet café table with a book, a phone, a cup and a glass of water

What the answers change

The answers decide the work. One client came to us for a new name. In the first meeting, their head of sales said the project would be a waste of money if customers still didn’t understand what the company did. The name wasn’t the problem. Nobody could explain the product in one sentence. We kept the name and spent the budget on the sentence.

Another client wanted a new look for their online shop because sales had fallen. When we asked our question, their finance lead said it would be wasted if people still gave up at the checkout. We looked at the numbers together. The look wasn’t losing them customers; a four-page checkout was. We fixed that first, and the redesign that followed was smaller and calmer than anyone expected.

Not every answer changes the project. Sometimes the brief was exactly right, and the question simply confirms it. That still matters. A team that has said its worries out loud works differently from one that hasn’t. They argue less about colours, because they’ve already agreed what the colours are for.

How we ask it

The wording matters less than the moment. We ask before we’ve shown anything, so nobody is defending a design. We ask everyone, not just the person paying. And we wait for the answer, even when the silence gets long.

We also ask it again, later. Halfway through a project, when the work is on the wall and opinions are forming, we put the original sheet back up and read the answers aloud. It’s a good way to settle an argument. Either the work is answering the worries we wrote down, or it isn’t.

When the answer is uncomfortable

Sometimes the honest answer is that the project shouldn’t happen yet. A company about to change owners. A product that hasn’t found its customers. A team that disagrees about what the business is for. A new identity won’t fix any of those, and it can make them harder to see.

When that happens, we say so. We’ve turned down work after that first meeting, and twice we’ve come back a year later to do it properly, once the business knew what it wanted to say.

Why it isn’t in the quote

Nobody budgets for a question, so we don’t charge for it. It’s an hour of our time, and it saves everyone far more than an hour. Projects that start with it run shorter, change direction less and end with fewer surprises.

It also changes the tone of everything after it. Once a team has told us what they’re afraid of, the rest of the project is easier to be honest about. Feedback gets more direct, because nobody is protecting a worry they haven’t mentioned.

There is a selfish reason too. We want to work on briefs we believe in. A brief we both understand, including the parts that are uncomfortable, is one we can do our best work on. A brief we’ve only nodded along to is one we’ll spend months quietly worrying about.

So if you come to see us with a project, expect the question. Bring the people who will have to live with the answer. And if you already know what would make it a waste of money, tell us first. It’s the most useful sentence in any brief.

An animator drawing a face on a light table

Next note

Teaching a logo to behave
Teaching a logo to behave
Teaching a logo to behave

A mark that moves has to stay itself. Our rules for motion that adds to an identity instead of performing on top of it.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.